Compare

Candy Cow vs Peppermint Shake

Candy Cow or Peppermint Shake? Pick any two flavors and see how their profiles and ingredients differ at a glance.

MustHave

Candy Cow

Milky caramel, like the classic "little cow" toffee candy.

Open Candy Cow

Trifecta

Peppermint Shake

A creamy vanilla shake with icy peppermint candy: a dessert mint.

Open Peppermint Shake
Try them together in the mixer

In short

Candy Cow is bolder, while Peppermint Shake is icier and fresher. Both have milk. Only in Candy Cow: caramel. Only in Peppermint Shake: vanilla & peppermint candy.

Profiles head to head

  • Sweetness: Candy Cow 9 out of 10, Peppermint Shake 8 out of 10
  • Freshness: Candy Cow 2 out of 10, Peppermint Shake 7 out of 10
  • Fruitiness: Candy Cow 0 out of 10, Peppermint Shake 0 out of 10
  • Mint / cooling: Candy Cow 0 out of 10, Peppermint Shake 6 out of 10
  • Flavor strength: Candy Cow 7 out of 10, Peppermint Shake 5 out of 10

Ingredients

Only Candy Cow

  • Caramel

Shared

  • Milk

Only Peppermint Shake

  • Vanilla
  • Peppermint candy

Popular comparisons